Why You’re Still in Pain Even Though Your MRI Is “Normal”

2 min read  •  
Home » Why You’re Still in Pain Even Though Your MRI Is “Normal”
Dr. Joseph Kottoor
Cartoon of MRI result and patient with a sore knee

One of the most common and frustrating things we hear from patients is:

“My MRI was normal… so why do I still hurt?”

If you’ve ever felt confused or discouraged by this, you’re not alone and you’re not imagining things.

Pain and Imaging Don’t Always Match

Decades of high-quality research show that pain does not correlate well with imaging findings.

Large studies have found that:

  • 60–80% of people with no pain at all have disc bulges, tendon changes, or joint “wear and tear” on MRI
  • At the same time, many people with persistent pain have scans that appear normal

A landmark New England Journal of Medicine study demonstrated that spinal abnormalities are extremely common in pain-free individuals. Similar findings exist for shoulders, knees, hips, and tendons.

Simply put: structure alone does not explain pain.

So, Why Does Pain Persist?

Pain reflects how well your body is tolerating the load, not just what the tissues look like.

Common contributors include:

  • Reduced strength or load tolerance
  • Altered movement patterns
  • Nervous system sensitivity
  • Training volume, stress, sleep, and recovery

This explains why two people with the same scan can feel completely different, and why symptoms can linger even when tissue looks “normal.” Function is just as important as, if not more important than, structure.

Why Rest Alone Often Isn’t Enough

Research in the British Journal of Sports Medicine and Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy shows that most musculoskeletal problems improve best with graded, progressive loading, not prolonged rest.

Tissues adapt to the demands placed on them. Without the right stimulus, tolerance doesn’t return—and pain can persist.

How Leaside Sports Medicine Can Help

Persistent pain usually means the system needs better guidance and not necessarily more tests or more rest.

At Leaside Sports Medicine, our role is to help you understand why your symptoms are happening and guide you safely back to movement and activity by improving your function. Our team is here to help.

You can book with any member of the team at Leaside Sports Medicine through the clinic’s Jane App booking page.

Book Appointment

Schedule an appointment with our sports medicine team

Book Now
Leaside Sports Medicine Reception Area
Share article:

Our Services

Radu Radulescu helping physiotherapy patient with hip mobility

Physiotherapy

With physiotherapy, we will use our expertise in the areas of biomechanics, movement assessment, exercise prescription, soft tissue techniques, and joint mobilization to effectively assess and treat a variety of conditions.

Dr. Kate Hood with chiropractic patient

Chiropractic

Our chiropractic treatments and manual therapies include adjustments, joint manipulation, active release techniques (ART), acupuncture, shockwave therapy, and more.

RMT performing massage therapy on patient

Massage Therapy

Our in-clinic Registered Massage Therapist will use their hands-on approach to work on your issues. In addition, they’ll remain coordinated with the LSM team and any other therapists who might be working with you to provide the most impactful and integrated care for you.

Dr. Darren Edelist performing sports medicine assessment

Sports Medicine

Our in-clinic sports medicine physician works with you to identify the root cause of your pain. From there, we'll create a comprehensive treatment plan to help you make a full recovery, achieve your goals, and get back to the activities you love.

Rachel Poole helping patient with banded exercises

Sports Physiotherapy

Our sports physiotherapists understand the demands of training and competition, creating treatment plans that directly support your goals. Whether you're dealing with a torn ligament, chronic pain, or post-surgery recovery, we'll get you back to what you love, stronger than before.

Pelvic Floor Physiotherapy Exercises

Pelvic Health Physiotherapy

Our skilled pelvic floor physiotherapists in Toronto are here to guide you through personalized treatment plans that address your unique pelvic floor symptoms and needs.